Federalism history and challenges in nepal madhesi youth. Nepals fiscal federalism model in the new constitution. The lie of the land for the main parties has changed substantially. In the most recent demographic health survey the gold standard for assessing.
I develop this proposal more formally here, showing how the definition of federalism can be derived from first principles within the context of a methodological and conceptual analysis. Study on intergovernmental fiscal transfers for federal nepal. Few points that will point out its importance are mentioned below. Executive summary the three rounds of election as nepal transitioned from a unitary to a federal state were the major issue in the political and developmental scene in the country in 2017. As the power sharing among the federal units is not properly defined it could create a puzzling situation. They contend with a challenging landscape of hills, high mountains and plains threatened by dangerous rivers, capricious weather, an. In the aftermath of the 2007 peoples revolt ii, the 240 years of monarchy was abolished in the 5th amendment of the interim constitution of nepal, 2063. Agenda for amendments 95 both the central and subnational levels. The activity empowers local governments, civil society and the nepali people in 10 municipalities of province 5 and. Nepals negotiation problems neglected aspect in bureaucracy focus on power, authority, status, position, not expertise and skills poor negotiating strategy weak straegic guidance to negotiators mandate deficiency little flexibility to negotiators lack of strong political support politicization of administrative issues. Yasho vardhan pradhan director general of the department of health services and dr. Jul 28, 2017 nepals 2015 constitution provides a federal structure, but in practice decentralization is being stalled.
They fear that especially ethnic federalism entrenches fragmentation along ethnic lines, introduces new dominance structures, and provides incentives to ethnopolitical mobilisation. So, with the view of proportional development in all the parts of the country by appropriate distribution and mobilization of resources and reducing the economic, social and religious discrimination, the country has transformed into a federal structure. However, the outer core, that is the structure of federalism, is not taking shape. In asia, some states introduced federalism following decolonization to hold together multiethnic communities, but others centralized and pursued a nationbuilding agenda. This chapter also outlines the debates within the constituent assembly and describes the model that was ultimately proposed by.
Variety of federations 25 countries and 40% of world population and 50% of surface of earth. Federalism and health in nepal 1 the author wishes to express thanks to. It was divided into a numerous principalities and kingdoms for a long time. Restructuring and federalism in nepal 2324 march 2007, kathmandu yash ghai1 i introduction while nepal has experienced much diversity of governments and styles of governance since 1990, there is widespread agreement that the nepali state remains highly centralised and provides little space for the participation of the people in public affairs. The federalism and the inclusive democracy as agreed upon by the political parties since the polarization of democratic forces in 2005, laid a framework for the promulgation of a new constitution for the country. Challenges and prospects of federalism in nepal purna man shakya associate professor, faculty of law tu background nepal is a small state tucked between india and china.
Box 2 nepals move towards federalism 51 tables table 1 key conditions, descriptions and scales 16 table 2 casestudy outcomes 21 table 3 sufficiency analysis for key conditions 42 table a1 necessity analysis. The amendment was the first document to mention nepal officially as the federal democratic republic of nepal. This concluded by positing a suggestion for a revised understanding of the federal concept. Federalism and constitution implementation search for common. At different points in time, the balance and boundaries between the national and state government have changed substantially. Postfederal analysis on marginalised communities in nepals. Federalism is seen as an in inclusive practice for nepal. Particularly after the april uprising of 2006, the trend of equating federalism with inclusion and social justice is dominant, but global empirical. The interim constitution of nepal, 2007 has adapted the inspiration of federalism and declared the provision of basic health care services free of cost as a fundamental right, which needs. Federalism contrasts with a unitary government, in which a central authority holds the power, and a confederation, a more or less permanent union of states with some or most political power vested in.
Brazil levies vat at both the central and state levels. Therefore, federalism was raised as a political agenda against the unitary system after the success of peoples movement ii, 2062063. As exemplified by the federal situation of other countries, power sharing can be a. The activity empowers local governments, civil society and. Concept of federalism federalism is a type of government in which the power is divided between the national government and other governmental units. The opposition ucpn maoist party chairman pushpa kamal dahal told nepals media after a visit to china in 20 that beijing was concerned that federalism would create further problems in nepal. Federalism has evolved over the course of american history. Ethnic and fiscal federalism in nepal lovise aalen and magnus hatlebakk cmi, bergen, norway. Federalism is not simply the decentralisation of political power. Pdf nepal is in the process of finalization of federal structures and this presentation bring different dimensions of federalization process and. Federalism in nepal the federal system of government in.
But given the common uneasiness with the redefinition of nepali national. The comprehensive peace agreement, signed in 2006, declared a formal end to a 10year rebel insurgency and placed constitutional change at the heart of the peacebuilding process. There are 27 countries in the world whose governments arc stmctured on federal ist principles, and 40% of the worlds population resides in. Pdf federalism in nepal major discourses and key challenges. Alexander hamilton, james madison, and george washington were advocates of the federal system. The largest is the russian federation 17m km 2, canada 9. History regional focusarea studies civil war communism democratization methods ethnic relations management demographic aspects indigenous peoplesgovernment relations political parties prime ministers. In the late 18 th century, prithvi narayan shah, the. Basis and limits of congressional power congressional research service summary the lines of authority between states and the federal government are, to a significant extent, defined by the united states constitution and relevant case law. Federalism is a means of ensuring peace, stability and mutual accommodation in countries that have territorially concentrated differences of identity, ethnicity, religion or language.
The inner core of federalism, as defined in the interim constitution of nepal 2007, and further refined in the constitution of nepal 2015, seems to be accelerating, albeit still at a slow pace. Postfederal analysis on marginalised communities in nepal. Nepals people live a constant struggle to accumulate some insulation from the hardships and arbitrariness of life. Executive summary this is the second report based on the study conducted by the project sundar santa nepal to understand the evolving dynamics of marginalisation and opportunities in the postfederal contexts by focusing on the.
Providing both a detailed theoretical examination and fresh case studies, it clearly distinguishes between federation, a particular kind of state, and federalism, the thinking that drives and promotes it. The quest for federalism in nepal forum of federations. The geopolitics of nepals federal structure the diplomat. Afp nepals uncertain transition to federalism 4 min read. Dec 28, 2017 likewise, federalism which is an experiment yet to be tested in nepal, accompanies several political risks, some of which are briefed below. Pathak chief of the policy, planning and international cooperation section of the ministry of health and population. Peace mediation essentials federalism and peace mediation even aim at preparing the ground for secession at a later point. Theories on the origin of federalism generally only apply to comingtogether federalism.
Prakashan 2010 constitutional history of nepal and constitutional. Likewise, federalism which is an experiment yet to be tested in nepal, accompanies several political risks, some of which are briefed below. Federalism or devolution involves the organization of public power so that government on at least two levels is responsive and accountable to the people that it serves. Mapping federalism in nepal conciliation resources.
Nepals federalism is in jeopardy the diplomat all sections search. Are there any qualifying indicators to be a federal state. Outline of presentation nasc, trilochan pokharel 10182014 3 grounds and basis for state restructuring principles of federalism progress in state restructuring and federalism in nepal. Federalism, state sovereignty, and the constitution. Democracy and peace in federal nepal international alert.
Constitutional mandate political, judiciary, administrative. Federalism in nepal entails three levels of government. There are some fundamental factors that explain why this is the case. The left alliance has culminated in a surprising result of nepals firstever federal elections, with a new path forged for consolidating democracy and peace, and institutionalising federalism. In canada, the federal government levies value added tax and provinces levy retail sales taxes. Federal system of government, i think, is actually not suitable for a small country like nepal but as for now let us assume that it is important. The first ever mention of a form of federalism in nepal was in the early 1950s. Identity politics and federalism executive summary federal restructuring of the state has emerged as a major demand of ethnic and regional ac tivists in nepal. The reasons behind nepals need to adopt federalism are. Nepals 2015 constitution provides a federal structure, but in practice decentralization is being stalled.
The constitutional amendments made after constituent assembly elections declared nepal a federal republic. The nepal tarai congress established in 1951 in the fluid political situation that followed the collapse of the rana regime, listed among its objectives recognising hindi as a state language, employing people from the tarai in public service, and establishing the tarai as an autonomous region. No any defined rules and regulations for a country to be federal or unitary. Federalism discourse in nepal ngo federation of nepal. The smallest is st kitts and nevis 261 km 2 followed by micronesia 702 km some have very large populations. Teplitz although the past decade has witnessed a dramatic improvement in the health of nepalis, including declines in infant and maternal mortality, reductions in chronic malnutrition, and an overall jump in life expectancy, significant health care service gaps persist. There are 27 countries in the world whose governments arc stmctured on federal ist principles, and 40% of the worlds population resides in these 27 countries. Introduction multiparty democracy was introduced in nepal in 1990 after a popular uprising led by the congress party and the united left front, a coalition of communist parties. The source of their knowledge is confined to media reporting and populist campaigning by limbu. Federalism, especially in large or diverse countries, can also improve service delivery and democratic resilience, ensure decisions are made at. Therefore, in the new experience of the federal system in nepal, it is important to prepare a very scientific and pragmatic equalization grant formula for nepal to effectively implement the expenditure assignment to local level as provided by the new constitution. It assigns powers and duties to each, through three exclusive lists and two concurrent lists of competencies. Whether federalism is a right model of governance for a multiethnic, multilingual and multireligious country like nepal has become a matter of great debate and discussion over the last decade. Economic surveys, budget speeches and plan documents published by the ministry of.
Federalism was not established in asia again until nepals new constitution of 2015. Frustrated by unrequited demands for recognition as a scheduled tribe st, gujjar protesters met grave ends as police opened fire on the crowds. Identity politics and federalism crisis group asia report n199, january 2011 page ii interests in the restructuring process. Executive summary this is the second report based on the study conducted by the project sundar santa nepal to understand the evolving dynamics of marginalisation and opportunities in the post federal contexts by focusing on the. Promonarchy groups and the hindu right are less concerned with federalism than with the republic and s ecularism. The reasons behind nepals need to adopt federalism are the peoples political aspirations, wishes and demands. The role of federal governments conference paper pdf available september 2016 with 2,394 reads how we measure reads. The foundation which was put forward in the 90s was at peak during madhesh movement after the promulgation of interim constitution in 2007 which resulted into introduction of federalism. It envisioned federalism as a prominent feature for a new nepal the maoist party was the catalyst for. It envisioned federalism as a prominent feature for a new nepal the maoist party was the catalyst for bringing forth.
Will nepals ongoing restructuring of the government improve the performance of the. In this discourse, five major perspectives have emerged, defining the nature of ethnic federalism in nepal. Two steps forward one step back the nepal peace process accord issue 26. May 04, 2018 federal system of government, i think, is actually not suitable for a small country like nepal but as for now let us assume that it is important. Pathak chief of the policy, planning and international cooperation section. This research is part of the sundar santa nepal project managed by international alert and implemented through a consortium of saferworld, bbc media action, and local partners samargra jana utthan kendra, jan jagaran club, support nepal, united youth community nepal, mahuri home and nepal madesh foundation.
43 190 66 973 959 223 649 463 891 728 1453 727 938 510 429 784 1144 1118 753 169 573 1069 1323 141 450 376 1063 858 978 211 905